(Private Collection)
Nobody likes to be shouted at or spoken to in an abusive, combative tone. In the Victorian era, however, such behavior was especially distasteful when engaged in by a man and directed at a woman. Men were generally larger in size and more powerful in position. It was their duty as gentlemen to treat women with respect, whether those women be the lowliest of servants or the grandest of ladies.
Etiquette books of the day offered plenty of advice on the subject of a gentleman’s behavior toward the so-called weaker sex. For instance, in his 1873 book The Gentlemen’s Book of Etiquette and Manual of Politeness, Cecil B. Hartley states that “civility is particularly due to all women,” even those women who were abusive or provoking. He explains:
“The greatest man would justly be reckoned a brute if he were not civil to the meanest woman. It is due to their sex, and is the only protection they have against the superior strength of ours.”
This sentiment is echoed in the 1877 book The Ladies’ and Gentlemen’s Etiquette, in which Eliza Bisbee Duffey argues that “a true gentleman” should always be “helpful and protecting to the weak.” As such:
“Women—all women, of whatever age or condition—claim his respectful care and tender and reverential regard.”
(Museu Nacional de Belas Artes)
There was no excuse for a man to speak harshly, either to a woman or in the presence of one. No matter the circumstances, a true Victorian gentleman was always supposed to control his temper and moderate his tone. According to the 1889 Hand-Book of Official and Social Etiquette and Public Ceremonials at Washington:
“Exhibitions of excitement, impatience or anger in the presence of ladies are a disrespect, no matter what may have happened.”
Gentlemen of fiery disposition were advised to keep a firm hold on their tempers when in company with females. Hartley instructs his male readers:
“Learn to restrain anger. A man in a passion ceases to be a gentleman, and if you do not control your passions, rely upon it, they will one day control you.”
For those gentlemen who needed added incentive to remain civil toward a provoking female, Hartley offers the following advice:
“If you are ever tempted to speak against a woman, think first—‘Suppose she were my sister!'”
Men who verbally attacked women were no gentlemen. Even worse, they were seen as cowardly. The sort of fellows who, according to Hartley, would “absolutely be afraid, to speak against a man, or that same woman, had she a manly arm to protect her.”
Instead, gentlemen were urged to take an almost paternalistic view toward the females they encountered. It was more than refraining from shouting at a woman or holding the occasional door. There were hundreds of little services a Victorian gentleman might perform. Anything and everything, from offering his arm to help a lady cross a street to giving up his seat on a public conveyance.
Today, there is greater (though still not perfect) equality between the sexes. Most women prefer to be treated as equals rather than put on a pedestal. Nevertheless, the sight of a man being verbally aggressive toward a woman still makes many of us uncomfortable. Is it because the behavior is ungentlemanly? Or because—given the physical and power differential—it’s downright abusive? As always, I’ll let you be the judge.
Sources
Cooke, Maud C. Social Etiquette; or Manners and Customs of Polite Society. Boston: Geo M. Smith & Co., 1896.
Duffey, Eliza Bisbee. The Ladies’ and Gentlemen’s Etiquette. Philadelphia: Porter and Coates, 1877.
Hartley, Cecil B. The Gentlemen’s Book of Etiquette and Manual of Politeness. Boston: J. S. Locke & Company, 1873.
Keim, De Benneville Randolph. Hand-Book of Official and Social Etiquette and Public Ceremonials at Washington. Washington: 1889.
On Sale Now
The Matrimonial Advertisement
England, 1860. When ex-army captain Justin Thornhill places an advertisement for a wife, the mysterious lady who answers isn’t quite what he was expecting. Find out more or Read an excerpt
Order Today
Amazon | Barnes & Noble | Kobo | iBooks
Praise for The Matrimonial Advertisement
“Matthews’ (The Pug Who Bit Napoleon, 2018, etc.) series opener is a guilty pleasure, brimming with beautiful people, damsels in distress, and an abundance of testosterone…It’s a well-written and engaging story that’s more than just a romance.” -Kirkus Reviews
“Matthews’ (The Viscount and the Vicar’s Daughter) has a knack for creating slow-building chemistry and an intriguing plot with a social history twist.” –Library Journal
“Ms. Matthews writes with elegance and precision…The author’s research is impeccable…She also makes excellent use of the remote coastal setting, creating a brooding atmosphere reminiscent of the gothic romances of the time with her evocative descriptions…” -All About Romance
“There’s no way this book could be anything but a historical and a mid Victorian one at that…The initial scary, isolated setting is haunting and leaves you ready to jump at what might come around the corner. The tension is palpable.” -Dear Author
“I absolutely loved every minute I spent with The Matrimonial Advertisement. Mimi Matthews is an exceptional story-teller.” -Passages to the Past
“Gothic Victorian story-telling at its best. This is how this genre is supposed to be written!…By far one of the best books I have read–ever!” -Chicks, Rogues and Scandals
© 2015-2019 Mimi Matthews
For exclusive information on upcoming book releases, giveaways, and other special treats, subscribe to Mimi’s newsletter THE PENNY NOT SO DREADFUL.
You can also connect with Mimi on Facebook and Twitter.
As always Mimi, you are very timely with your articles. Treating all others civilly may be a forgotten art that is no longer being practiced by all…I take this as a gentle reminder. Thank you!
I’m so glad you enjoyed it :)
These days I think we can remove the whole question of gender and simply say that it is despicable to behave abusively, either verbally or physically, to anyone who is weaker or in a weaker position than you are. So that covers all the atrocious behaviour by women to women or women to men (or children) which is just as common now as bad behaviour by men.
I completely agree, Jane. Nowadays, I think so much of what would have once been considered “gentlemanly” is just common courtesy to every human. Holding doors for people whose arms are full, giving your seat on the bus to a pregnant woman or someone who is disabled, etc. Unfortunately, some of these civilities, seem to have slipped away over time. I suspect that sometimes, when we’re out and about, we’re all just so much in our own world we aren’t as in tune to the needs of strangers anymore.
While I can do without the whole patronizing, weaker sex thing, I completely agree that men should treat women with civility. So should women treat men with civility – in fact, this world would be a much pleasanter place if we all treated each other with kindness and civility – and I include animals with that. IMO, one of the true signs of a gentleman is one who is kind to animals.
I absolutely agree, Pam, especially about the kindness to animals. Ultimately, civility should be something practiced by all. It shouldn’t be something you’re only entitled to if you’re a woman, weak or otherwise.
Many thanks for this informative article. I agree with the others that in the end, civility and decency is for everyone and should be practised by all. What’s interesting is how there was really a rather condescending attitude towards women that’s dressed up as chivalry and gentlemanly behaviour.
I’m glad you enjoyed it! And I agree about the condescending attitude. Most of it seems based on the belief that women were inherently weaker, in both body and mind.