The Solitary Vice: Victorian Views on Masturbation

Woman's Mission: Companion of Manhood by George Elgar Hicks, 1863.(Tate Museum)
Woman’s Mission: Companion of Manhood by George Elgar Hicks, 1863.
(Tate Museum)

During the Victorian era, masturbation—also known as self-pollution, self-abuse, or onanism—was believed to be both a moral and a physical evil.  Medical manuals of the era address it in the most severe terms, blaming male masturbation, and the resulting depletion of the body’s vital humors, for every imaginable illness, from blindness, impotence, and epilepsy to chronic fatigue, mental derangement, and even premature death.  Many of these beliefs can be traced back to two 18th century books, the most significant of which was Samuel Tissot’s famous 1760 medical treatise On Onania: or A Treatise upon the Disorders Produced by Masturbation, which asserts:

“Frequent emissions of semen relax, weaken, dry, enervate the body, and produce numerous other evils, as apoplexies, lethargies, epilepsies, loss of sight, trembling, paralysis, and all kinds of painful affections.”

By the 19th century, concerns about the evil effects of masturbation had risen to epic proportions.  The solitary vice was being discussed in medical texts and religious treatises.  And the Victorians—who ascribed moral value to self-discipline and restraint—were driven to devise various means of discouraging and controlling it.

The Crime

According to physicians R. and L. Perry in their 1847 book The Silent Friend: A Medical Work on the Disorders Produced by the Dangerous Effects of Onanism:

“The practice of the solitary vice, onanism, manustupration or masturbation has been condemned by all writers, whether medical men, philosophers, or divines, from the earliest ages of mankind.  One of its names, onanism, is derived from the saddening example of Onan the second son of Judah, who was struck dead by his Creator for the commission of this heinous sin.”

The Secret Companion by R J Brodie, 1845.(Image via Wellcome Library, CC By 4.0)
The Secret Companion by R J Brodie, 1845.
(Image via Wellcome Library, CC By 4.0)

In his 1845 book, The Secret Companion: A Medical Work on Onanism or Self-Pollution, consulting surgeon R. J. Brodie calls masturbation a perverted inclination and a baneful habit which “destroys the germ of manhood.”  While Dr. William Acton, in his 1894 book on The Functions and Disorders of the Reproductive Organs, refers to masturbation as a “melancholy and repulsive habit” that is “degrading and debilitating to the child” and injurious to the adult.  Acton advises young men to give up the practice as early as possible, warning them that:

“When once the vile habit has become confirmed, the young libertine runs the risk of finding himself, a few years later, but a debauched old man.”

Brodie is equally severe.  He blames self-abuse on “licentiousness and unrestrained indulgence of the passions,” writing:

“Sages and moral writers of every age, have described in glowing terms the direful and awful result of Masturbation a passion that captivates the imagination of its victim imperceptibly, step by step, till every moral feeling is obliterated, and all the physical powers destroyed.”

The Consequences

According to many moral and medical texts of the Victorian era, not only did masturbation weaken the mind and body, it also weakened the soul.  As Brodie explains (quoting M. Hoffman):

“We can easily comprehend, how there is so close a connection between the brain and testicles; because these two organs secern from the blood the most subtle and exquisite lympha, which is destined to give strength and motion to the parts, and to assist even the functions of the soul.  So it is probable, that too great a dissipation of these liquors may destroy the powers of the soul, and body.”

The Secret Companion by R J Brodie, 1845.(Image via Wellcome Library, CC By 4.0)
The Secret Companion by R J Brodie, 1845.
(Image via Wellcome Library, CC By 4.0)

However, as much as masturbation was considered a moral evil and potential destroyer of one’s soul, the bulk of the consequences resulting from self-abuse were believed to accrue to the body.  In an 1843 issue of the Edinburgh Medical and Surgical Journal, Dr. William Mackenzie, Surgeon-Oculist to Queen Victoria, writes:

“…masturbation is often followed by loss of appetite, indigestion, headach[sic], vertigo, tinnitus aurium, rigors, flushings, constant clamminess of the hands, want of sleep, signs of congestion or chronic inflammation of the brain, apoplectic symptoms, palpitation of the heart, and emaciation, leading to a suspicion of phthisis.  Palsy and insanity are not unfrequent consequences of masturbation.”

In The Secret Companion, Brodie includes several case studies of individuals suffering terribly from the consequences of over-indulgence in the solitary vice.  In most of the studies, the patient picked up the habit while still a boy in school.  For example, Brodie describes one patient as:

“R.I., aged twenty, of slender form, sunken eyes, pallid countenance, and considerable emaciation, stated that when placed at a public school, at the age of twelve, he had been induced by his school-fellows to indulge in the habit of self-pollution…”

While in another case, Brodie describes a gentleman of “profound learning” who declared “with the deepest anguish” that:

“…the fruits of his academical labours would never compensate for the mischief incurred from a solitary vice taught him by a depraved companion, when he was about thirteen years of age.”

Masturbation by Mihály Zichy, 1911.
Masturbation by Mihály Zichy, 1911.

There were many similar cases wherein the patient had learned the particulars of self-abuse from his schoolfellows only to continue the practice as an adult—at which point, the patient’s health inevitably suffered.  In one case, Brodie describes a man so affected by the consequences of self-pollution that he “less resembled a living creature than a corpse.”  Confined to a straw mattress, where he languished in considerable pain, the patient could do nothing all day but reflect on the evils of masturbation.  Brodie writes:

“Thus overwhelmed in misery, he languished almost without any assistance for some months, and was the more to be pitied, for what memory he had remaining, and which he was at length entirely bereft of, only served him to take an incessant retrospect of the cause of his misfortunes, which were increased by the aggravating horrors of remorse.”

The Cure

According to Brodie, the patient who wished for relief from the consequences of masturbation must first:

“…entirely discontinue this dreadful practice, however difficult to do so from the force of habit…”

The Electric Alarum for Treatment of Masturbation, 1887. (Image via Wellcome Library CC BY 4.0)
The Electric Alarum for Treatment of Masturbation, 1887.
(Image via Wellcome Library CC BY 4.0)

This was often easier said than done, especially for those patients who reported engaging in the solitary vice multiple times each day.  To aid the process, doctors frequently recommended changes in diet, an increase in physical activity, and prayer.  Visualization exercises were also sometimes recommended.  For instance, Acton quotes the advice of a clergyman on dealing with unhealthy impulses at night, writing:

“[If a] man is tormented by evil thoughts at night.  Let him be directed to cross his arms upon his breast, and extend himself as if he were lying in his coffin.  Let him endeavor to think of himself as he will be one day stretched in death.  If such solemn thoughts do not drive away evil imaginations, let him rise from his bed and lie on the floor.”

Four Pointed Urethral Ring for the Treatment of Masturbation, 1887.(Image via Wellcome Library CC BY 4.0)
Four Pointed Urethral Ring for the Treatment of Masturbation, 1887.
(Image via Wellcome Library CC BY 4.0)

For desperate cases, doctors sometimes recommended desperate measures.  There were cordials and various patent medicines (Brodie’s medical practice sold Cordial Balm of Zeylanica).  There were also more invasive types of “cures” such as spiked rings or electric shock devices for the genitals.  According to the book Sexualities in Victorian Britain, by the 1850s some doctors were even beginning to recommend circumcision as a treatment for masturbation.

But What About Women??

Most of what was written about the dangers of masturbation in the Victorian era was directed at men.  However, women were not entirely exempt.  According to author Joan Perkin in her 1993 book Victorian Women, some doctors believed that masturbation caused “increasing numbers of hysterical cases among girls.”  While others said that masturbation caused “certain forms of insanity, epilepsy and hysteria in females.”

Dr. Isaac Baker Brown, 1851.
Dr. Isaac Baker Brown, 1851.

At its most extreme, the cure for the solitary vice in women was grim.  Perkin mentions a gynecologist named Isaac Baker Brown who ran a clinic in London during the 1860s.  He called masturbation in women “anti-social behavior” and, as Perkin reports:

“His treatment was removal of the clitoris.”

Brown was not the only doctor during the Victorian era to perform clitoridectomies on girls and women, but the practice, as a whole, was extremely controversial.  Perkin points out that the total number of females operated on “must have been very small.”  As a side note, Brown was ultimately expelled from the Obstetrical Society

A Few Final Words…

Opinions on the physical and moral dangers of the solitary vice did not change rapidly.  Even today, there are some for whom the subject is still a controversial one.  However, rather than address modern day arguments, I will close this article by taking you back to the 19th century.  In his 1872 book on Male Continence, American preacher John Humphrey Noyes addresses masturbation in one particularly hilarious paragraph, writing:

“…it is obvious that before marriage men have no lawful method of discharge but masturbation; and after marriage it is as foolish and cruel to expend one’s seed on a wife merely for the sake of getting rid of it, as it would be to fire a gun at one’s best friend merely for the sake of unloading it.  If a blunderbuss must be emptied, and the charge cannot be drawn, it is better to fire into the air than to kill somebody with it.”

Mimi Matthews is the author of The Pug Who Bit Napoleon: Animal Tales of the 18th and 19th Centuries (to be released by Pen and Sword Books in November 2017).  She researches and writes on all aspects of nineteenth century history—from animals, art, and etiquette to fashion, beauty, feminism, and law. 

Sources

Acton, William.  The Functions and Disorders of the Reproductive Organs.  Philadelphia: P. Blakiston, 1894.

Brodie, R. J.  The Secret Companion: A Medical Work on Onanism or Self-Pollution.  London: R. J. Brodie & Co., 1845.

MacKenzie, William.  “On Asthenopia, or Weak-sightedness.”  The Edinburgh Medical and Surgical Journal.  Vol. 60.  Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black, 1843.

Noyes, John Humphrey.  Male Continence.  Oneida: Oneida Community, 1872.

Perkin, Joan.  Victorian Women.  New York: New York University Press, 1993.

Perry, R.  The Silent Friend: A Medical Work on the Disorders Produced by the Dangerous Effects of Onanism..  London: R. and L. Perry, 1847.

Sexualities in Victorian Britain.  Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1996.

Tissot, Samuel Auguste David.  A Treatise on the Diseases Produced by Onanism.  New York: Collins & Hannay, 1832.


© 2015-2017 Mimi Matthews

For exclusive information on upcoming book releases, giveaways, and other special treats, subscribe to Mimi’s newsletter THE PENNY NOT SO DREADFUL.

You can also connect with Mimi on Facebook and Twitter.

Leave a Reply

29 Comments on "The Solitary Vice: Victorian Views on Masturbation"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
woostersauce2014
Guest

Interesting how discussions on masturbation are clothed in hysteria and a lot of medical quackery. Not to mention how the term “solitary vice” says it all, its seen as unnatural because its not between two people and hence dangerous.

I did mention and discuss masturbation a bit in my own blog:
[link removed]

Mimi Matthews
Guest

Well said! And I completely agree about the term “solitary vice.” I’m sorry I had to remove your link. I stopped allowing links in the comments section a few months ago and I have to apply the rule evenly.

woostersauce2014
Guest

And it shows how much masturbation was viewed with suspicion. No worries, I wasn’t aware of the rule, had I known I would not have posted it but simply mentioned it.

Sarah
Guest

Ah, John Humphrey Noyes, you have just made my day! Brilliant!

Mimi Matthews
Guest

Glad you liked it, Sarah :) When I was typing that quote, I couldn’t stop laughing!

Sarah Waldock
Guest

Onan, actually, wasn’t masturbating when he spilled his seed, he was practising coitus interruptus because he was a greedy bastard who refused to get his brothers’ widows pregnant – the law being that if they had sons, the sons inherited from their former husbands and the widows were thus protected financially for life. This weird sort of law had vanished by the medieval era and so the story of Onan has been misinterpreted. Thanks to Vivi Schenk, Biblical Historian, for this explanation which made the whole weird story fall into place.

Mimi Matthews
Guest

Interesting! In the Victorian texts, Onan is associated with masturbation. Just lets you know how much history is distorted over time.

Sarah Waldock
Guest

it appears to be a medieval misinterpretation, which stuck….

Blog Author
Guest

Of course, then there was female hysteria in the Victorian Era when doctors thought that women who were over emotional needed sexual stimulation in the doctor’s office — not in the marriage bed. Women suffering from hysteria would undergo “pelvic massage” – manual stimulation of the genitals by the doctor until the patient experienced “hysterical paroxysm” (orgasm). Evil to do it alone to their own bodies but acceptable in the doctor’s office. If a physician did that today, he’d be in jail. Quite interesting how the matter was rationalized.

Mimi Matthews
Guest

It is an interesting dichotomy, isn’t it? So much about women’s feelings and natural physical responses was categorized under the catch-all of “Hysteria.” They had such a minimal understanding about women’s brains and bodies!

Vickie
Guest

Quite humorous now – but not so then – this must have been quite fun to research!

Mimi Matthews
Guest

It was lots of fun to research :) And thank goodness! Without the funny bits, the grim medical facts would have been even more depressing.

paper doll
Guest

“His treatment was removal of the clitoris.”

That stopped me in my tracks….Yikes! . Amazing post! Thank you

Mimi Matthews
Guest

Thanks so much :) The “cures” for women were definitely the most shocking part of my research.

PJMoore
Guest

How amusing of a topic! I got quite a giggle! :)

Mimi Matthews
Guest

I’m so glad you enjoyed it, PJ :)

trackback

[…] Source: The Solitary Vice: Victorian Views on Masturbation […]

Ann Marie Ackermann (@Ann_M_Ackermann)
Guest

For all that Victorian disdain for masturbation, Mark Twain delivered quite a humorous speech on the topic in 1879, “Some Thoughts on the Sicence of Onanism.” I’m providing a link — it’s worth a chuckle. He and John Humphrey Noyes would have gotten along quite well. [link removed]

Mimi Matthews
Guest

Thanks so much, Ann :) Leave it to Mark Twain! I didn’t know about that speech, but will definitely give it a read. Sorry about the link removal. I stopped allowing links a few months ago and I have to apply the rule evenly.

Barbara Monajem
Guest

Eons ago, I purchased a book at a jumble sale called “Man the Masterpiece.” It was a Victorian-era publication and had a page about self-abuse. No idea where it ended up, alas.

Mimi Matthews
Guest

Some of the old Victorian era books on male masturbation are just hilarious. Not so much for the men living in that time, though!

Noirfifre
Guest

I am sure the spike hooks and electric stuff gave more pleasure :P. Haha

Mimi Matthews
Guest

There’s something medieval about these “cures.” One can only hope that pleasure was an unintended side effect!

Noirfifre
Guest

Always unattended but the result haha, for example the massage for women. Possible law suit cures of today.

Renée Reynolds
Guest

Oh, after a rotten start to my week, this post was exactly what I needed! So much chuckling and eye rolling (except for that clitoris removal -!!)

I still wonder where the myth of hair palms and blindness arose.

Mimi Matthews
Guest

I’m so glad you enjoyed it, Renee :) I can’t tell you where the myth of blindness from masturbation arose, but it was certain alive and well in the Victorian era. Eye doctors–including Queen Victoria’s own eye doctor–really did believe that there was a connection.

Pam Shropshire
Guest

LOL! Reminds me of the Seinfeld episode, “The Contest,” in which George was caught masturbating by his mother and Jerry, Elaine and George try to see which can go the longest without. “I am the master of my domain!” *giggles*

Mimi Matthews
Guest

I remember that episode :) It’s interesting that nowadays the subject is more humorous than truly shameful. Perhaps there have always been those who thought it was funny? If not, I wonder when attitudes began to change?

trackback

[…] Mimi Mathews: The Solitary Vice: Victorian Views on Masturbation […]

wpDiscuz