Outlander, Austen, and Quick: The Emotionally Vulnerable Hero

“In vain I have struggled.  It will not do.  My feelings will not be repressed.  You must allow me to tell you how ardently I admire and love you.”

Permission Details The use of this photograph has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this photograph is reproduced on this site without profit and for the purposes of criticism, comment, scholarship, and research. It therefore qualifies as FAIR USE. If you wish to use this copyrighted photograph for purposes of your own that go beyond Fair Use, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
Pride and Prejudice (1995). Photograph: BBC

So says Mr. Darcy to Elizabeth Bennett in what is not only one of the most famous scenes in Pride and Prejudice but arguably one of the most beloved in all of English Literature.  Darcy’s anxiety upon entering the room, sitting down, standing up, walking about, and finally declaring his love for Elizabeth in a highly “agitated manner,” has set many of our 21st century hearts soaring.  Why is it then that in most modern historical romances the dynamic of the relationship portrayed is the complete reverse?

Pride and Prejudice First Edition
Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen.
(First Edition)

How many historical romance novels have we read where the heroine spends the entirety of the book anguishing over what the hero feels for her?  And how many have we read where the heroine tells the hero “I love you” one hundred pages in, but does not have her feelings reciprocated until the final pages of the very last chapter?

This dynamic in historical novels has clearly had a great deal of appeal over the years.  During the era of the bodice-ripper, especially, the hero’s inability to express emotion often stood as an example of his strength and masculinity.  Indeed, for some readers, even the slightest sign of vulnerability in a hero was tantamount to weakness.

That’s not to say that those types of novels can’t be enjoyable to read.  However, if you’re like me and  prefer your heroes to have an occasional spasm of uncertainty when it comes to the heroine – or even to declare their love long before the heroine declares hers – you will be happy to know that amongst all the coldly remote alpha-males populating historical romance today, the self-doubting, emotionally vulnerable hero still exists.

Permission Details The use of this photograph has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this photograph is reproduced on this site without profit and for the purposes of criticism, comment, scholarship, and research. It therefore qualifies as FAIR USE. If you wish to use this copyrighted photograph for purposes of your own that go beyond Fair Use, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
Outlander (2014). Photograph: Starz.

In Diana Gabaldon’s Outlander, we meet James Fraser.  Set primarily in 18th century Scotland during the second Jacobite Rebellion, no one could ever doubt our Highland hero’s masculinity.  Yet when it comes to our heroine, Claire, Jamie is anything but overconfident.

Outlander Jamie
Outlander (2014). Photograph: Starz.

Whether he’s self-consciously smoothing down the “spiky licks” of his hair, sheepishly confessing to the efforts he put in to dressing for his wedding (“I wished to do ye honor today by looking as well as I might”), or coloring with “a slow, fierce blush” at the very mention of consummating his marriage, Outlander’s James Fraser, for all his warrior-like prowess, is possessed of an irresistible emotional vulnerability that could melt the heart of even the most indifferent female.

And yes, he is the first to declare his feelings.

“I wanted ye from the first I saw ye—,” he admits to Claire, “but I loved ye when you wept in my arms and let me comfort you, that first time at Leoch.”

In Amanda Quick’s new novel, Garden of Lies, I was pleased to come across another emotionally vulnerable hero.

Permission Details The use of this photograph has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this photograph is reproduced on this site without profit and for the purposes of criticism, comment, scholarship, and research. It therefore qualifies as FAIR USE. If you wish to use this copyrighted photograph for purposes of your own that go beyond Fair Use, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
Garden of Lies by Amanda Quick (2015).

Victorian archaeologist and adventurer Slater Roxton is, in the manner of many classic Quick heroes, intelligent, physically formidable, and of course, mysterious.  There are a lot of things to like about Garden of Lies and plenty of reasons to keep reading through to the end, but what most intrigued me was the hero’s emotional reaction to the heroine.

Having known Ursula Kern, head of the Kern Secretarial Agency, less than a fortnight, Slater has already fallen desperately in love with her, drawn, as he says, “Like a damned moth to her flame.”  When Ursula departs Slater’s house early in the novel after giving notice that she cannot work for him anymore, he is devastated.

“He stood at the window in the front hall and watched until the carriage vanished into the fog.  Everything inside him went cold.  He was losing her.  You never possessed her.  She was not yours to lose.”

Amidst the action, adventure, and mystery of the novel, we are treated to several glimpses of Slater’s private thoughts and insecurities which reveal the inner vulnerability of this outwardly invulnerable character.  After their first romantic interlude, for example, when Ursula does not immediately express her feelings, we see Slater go through what thousands of heroines in other historical romances have gone through over the years – the uncertainty and doubt over whether the object of their love returns their affections.

“His spirits, which had been in fine form a moment ago, were suddenly plunged into the depths.  He exhaled deeply.  What had he expected from her?  A declaration of undying passion?”

Heroes are heroic, by definition, but this does not mean they are inhuman.  As a reader, I greatly appreciate those authors who understand that vulnerability in a historical romance hero is neither weak nor anachronistic.  And those authors are out there, I assure you.  Authors like Austen, Gabaldon, and Quick, whose novels give us the whole picture of a hero – doubts, insecurities, blushes and all.

Mimi Matthews is the author of The Pug Who Bit Napoleon: Animal Tales of the 18th and 19th Centuries (to be released by Pen and Sword Books in November 2017).  She researches and writes on all aspects of nineteenth century history—from animals, art, and etiquette to fashion, beauty, feminism, and law. 

Sources

Austen, Jane. Pride and Prejudice. New York: Modern Library, 1995.

Gabaldon, Diana. Outlander. New York: Delacorte, 1991. 


Available Now

The Lost Letter
A Victorian Romance

England, 1860. An impoverished beauty is unexpectedly reunited with the beastly earl who jilted her three years before. Will they finally find their happily ever after? Or are some fairy-tale endings simply not meant to be? Find out more…

ORDER TODAY for $2.99 or
FREE on KINDLE UNLIMITED!

Amazon | Amazon UK


Advance Praise for The Lost Letter

“This sweet story is the perfect quick read for fans of Regency romances as well as Victorian happily-ever-afters, with shades of Austen and the Brontës that create an entertaining blend of drama and romance.” -RT Book Reviews

“Debut author Matthews adroitly captures the internal conflicts of her two main characters…The author’s prose is consistently refined and elegant, and she memorably builds the simmering attraction between Sylvia and Sebastian.” –Kirkus Reviews

“A fast and emotionally satisfying read, with two characters finding the happily-ever-after they had understandably given up on. A promising debut.” -Library Journal

“An extremely romantic and emotional story… The characters are so realistic and just walk off the page and into your heart. This love story will stay in my memory for some time to come. This is a definite keeper that I can highly recommend.” -The Romance Reviews

“Absolutely remarkable!…Right up there with the best books I have read this year…Beautiful, romantic and emotionally shattering…One of those books that you keep on the bookshelf forever…Flawless!” -Chicks, Rogues and Scandals

“In a sweet Victorian setting, Beauty and the Beast is retold in a two and a half hour read that will have your heart doing somersaults the whole time.” -Book Ink Reviews


© 2015-2017 Mimi Matthews

For exclusive information on upcoming book releases, giveaways, and other special treats, subscribe to Mimi’s newsletter THE PENNY NOT SO DREADFUL.

You can also connect with Mimi on Facebook and Twitter.

Leave a Reply

7 Comments on "Outlander, Austen, and Quick: The Emotionally Vulnerable Hero"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Sarah Waldock
Guest

It boils down to that old adage that a woman loves to be loved, adores to be adored and NEEDS TO BE NEEDED.
We, the stronger sex, need our menfolk to be dependent on us…

Mimi Matthews
Guest

I’ve never heard that before! I think there must be some truth in it. :)

bevieann61
Guest

Reblogged this on bevieann61's Blog. about books!!! and commented:
Very good information

Mimi Matthews
Guest

Thanks, Bevieann!

bevieann61
Guest

Your welcome

Angelyn
Guest

Good post–puts a finger on the problem of characterization in today’s fiction (and mine, in particular!)

Mimi Matthews
Guest

It’s a good thing there’s a range of heroes and so many books to choose from – though I read one recently where the hero could not stop crying and that was a bit too emotionally vulnerable for my taste… ;) Thanks for commenting, Angelyn!

wpDiscuz